View source for Tulku

{{Short description|Title in Tibetan Buddhism}}
{{About||the 2009 film|Tulku (film)}}
{{redirect|Living Buddha|the practice of live mummification in some Buddhist sects|Sokushinbutsu}}
{{Tibetan Buddhism}}
A '''''tulku''''' ({{bo|t=སྤྲུལ་སྐུ་|w=sprul sku|z=Zhügu}}, also '''''tülku''''', '''''trulku''''') is a distinctive and significant aspect of [[Tibetan Buddhism]], embodying the concept of enlightened beings taking corporeal forms to continue the lineage of specific teachings. The term "tulku" has its origins in the Tibetan word "sprul sku", which originally referred to an emperor or ruler taking human form on Earth, signifying a divine incarnation. Over time, this term evolved within Tibetan Buddhism to denote the corporeal existence of highly accomplished Buddhist masters whose purpose is to ensure the preservation and transmission of a particular lineage.
The tulku system originated in Tibet, particularly associated with the recognition of the second [[Karmapa]] in the 13th century. Since then, numerous tulku lineages have been established, with each tulku having a distinctive role in preserving and propagating specific teachings. Other high-profile examples of tulkus include the [[Dalai Lamas]], the [[Panchen Lama]]s, the [[Samding Dorje Phagmo]]s, [[Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo#Tulkus|Khyentses]], the [[Zhabdrung Rinpoche]]s, and the [[Jamgon Kongtrul#Tulkus|Kongtruls]].
The process of recognizing tulkus involves a combination of traditional and supernatural methods. When a tulku passes away, a committee of senior lamas convenes to identify the reincarnation. They may look for signs left by the departed tulku, consult oracles, rely on dreams or visions, and sometimes even observe natural phenomena like rainbows. This process combines mysticism and tradition to pinpoint the successor who will carry forward the teachings of their predecessor.
A [[Western tulku]] is the recognized successor to a lama or dharma master born in the West, commonly of non-[[Tibetan people|Tibetan]] ethnic heritage. This recognition has sparked debates and discussions regarding the cultural adaptation and authenticity of Westerners within the traditional Tibetan tulku system. Some argue that Westerners should explore their own forms of Buddhism rather than attempting to fit into this system. Western tulkus may struggle to gain recognition among laypeople and even other monastics. Generally, Western tulkus do not follow traditional Tibetan monastic life, and commonly leave their home monasteries for alternative careers, not necessarily chaplaincy.{{sfn|Ary|2012|p=426}}
==Etymology and meaning==
The word སྤྲུལ or 'sprul' (Modern Lhasa Tibetan {{IPA|[ʈʉl]}}) was a verb in Old Tibetan literature and was used to describe the བཙན་པོ་ btsanpo ('emperor'/天子){{Citation needed|reason=Source needed for this claim|date=February 2018}} taking a human form on earth. So the ''sprul'' idea of taking a corporeal form is a local religious idea alien to Indian Buddhism and other forms of Buddhism (e.g. Theravadin or Zen). The term ''tülku'' became associated with the translation of the [[Sanskrit]] philosophical term ''[[nirmanakaya]]''. According to the philosophical system of ''[[trikaya]]'' or ''three bodies of Buddha'', nirmanakaya is the Buddha's "body" in the sense of the [[bodymind]] (Sanskrit: ''[[namarupa|nāmarūpa]]''). Thus, the person of [[Siddhartha Gautama]], the historical Buddha, is an example of nirmanakaya.
Over time, indigenous religious ideas became assimilated by the new Buddhism; e.g. ''sprul'' became part of a compound noun, སྤྲུལ་སྐུ་'sprul.sku' ("incarnation body" or 'tülku', and 'btsan', the term for the imperial ruler of the Tibetan Empire, became a kind of mountain deity). Valentine summarizes the shift in meaning of the word ''tülku'': "This term that was originally used to describe the Buddha as a 'magical emanation' of enlightenment, is best translated as 'incarnation' or 'steadfast incarnation' when used in the context of the tulku system to describe patriarchs that reliably return to human form."{{sfn|Valentine|2013}}
According to the ''Light of Fearless Indestructible Wisdom'' by Khenpo Tsewang Dongyal: the term ''tülku'' "designates one who is 'noble' (or 'selfless' according to Buddha's usage) and used in Buddhist texts to denote a highly achieved being who has attained the first bhumi, a level of attainment which is truly egoless, or higher."{{quote without source|date=November 2023}} Higher [[Vajrayana]] practitioners who have attained siddhis and mastered the [[bardo]] of dying, bardo of dharmata or bardo of becoming can be reborn as a tülkus.{{sfn|Pelzang|2004|p={{page needed|date=November 2023}}}} According to Khenpo Ngawang Pelzang:
{{blockquote|This form of transference is practiced by beginners on the path of accumulating who have received empowerment and respected the samayas, have a good understanding of the view, and have practiced the generation phase as the path but have not mastered it. Although they lack the necessary confidence to be liberated in the clear light at the moment of death or in the intermediate state of absolute reality, by taking refuge and praying to their teacher in the intermediate state they can close the way to an unfavorable womb and choose a favorable rebirth. Propelled by compassion and bodhichitta, they depart to a pure buddhafield or, failing that, take birth as a tulku born to parents who practice the Dharma. In that next life they will be liberated.{{sfn|Pelzang|2004|p={{page needed|date=November 2023}}}} }}
In addition to Tibet, Tibetan Buddhism is a traditional religion in China and Mongolia. The Mongolian word for a ''tülku'' is ''qubilγan'', though such persons may also be called by the honorific title ''qutuγtu'' (Tib: '''phags-pa'' and Skt: ''ārya ''or ''superior'', not to be confused with the historic figure, 'Phags-pa Lama or the script attributed to him, ([['Phags-pa script|''Phags-pa'' script]]), or ''hutagt'' in the standard [[Khalkha Mongolian|Khalkha dialect]]. The Chinese word for ''tülku'' is ''huófó'' (活佛), which literally means "living Buddha".
==Grades==
Tibetans recognize at least three grades of tulku. Three of these grades as reported by Peter Bishop are:{{sfn|Bishop|1993|p=63}}
*''Low-level lamas'' – any monk who has been rewarded with a human rebirth
*''Nearly perfected beings'' – these are highly skilled practitioners who intentionally reincarnate to fulfill a specific purpose or mission
*''Incarnate Bodhisattvas'' – the fullest sense of tulku, this grade includes only the major tulku lineages such as the [[Karmapa]]s, the [[Dalai Lama]]s, and the [[Tai Situpa]]s.
==History==
In a strict sense, ''tulku'' is a Tibetan translation of the [[Sanskrit]] ''[[nirmāṇakāya]]'', which refers to the "transformation" or "emanation body" of a [[Buddha]]. ''Tulku'' is therefore the physical "form in which a Buddha appears to ordinary beings."{{sfn | Ary | 2012 | pp=399–400}}
A related term in Tibetan is ''yangsi'' (literally "rebirth" or "re-becoming") which refers to an enlightened master who has returned to earthly existence for the sake of benefitting sentient beings. While the notion of a nirmāṇakāya is found throughout [[Mahayana]] Buddhism, and is integral to the doctrine of the ''[[trikaya]]'' ("Three Bodies"), the concept of the ''yangsi'' is uniquely Tibetan. Tulku, as a title, refers to one who is recognized as the yangsi of a master.{{sfn | Ary | 2012 | pp=400–401}}
It arose in the context of a political vacuum spurred by the assassination of [[Ralpachen]], which saw monastic centers develop political power in a second spreading of Buddhism in Tibet.{{sfn| Ray | 1986 | p=44}} It had "purely politico-mercantile origins and functions"{{sfn|Ary|2012|p=409}} and later became a significant spiritual institution. However, some commentators argue that the political shift was "grafted onto the tradition of recognizing reincarnations, not the other way around."{{sfn|Ary|2012|p=409}} [[Turrell V. Wylie]] wrote that the tulku system "developed in Tibetan Buddhism primarily for political reasons"{{sfn|Ray|1986|p=37}} while Reginald Ray argued that such a view ignores "miss[es] what is perhaps its most distinctive feature" which is its "important ideological and religious dimensions",{{sfn| Ray | 1986 | p={{page needed|date=November 2023}}}} being "deeply rooted" in the ''[[bodhisattva]]'' concept.{{sfn| Ray | 1986 | p=37}}
Tulku have been associated with ruling power since its origination, expressing indigenous Tibetan notions of kingship.{{sfn| Ray | 1986 | p=43}} This system supplanted the earlier model of monastic governance, in which a celibate religious head acted as abbot, while his brother, a married administrative head, continued the family line, with his eldest son becoming the next religious head, creating an uncle-nephew system of inheritance.{{sfn| Ray | 1986 | p=45}} The first recognized tulku was perhaps [[Rangjung Dorje, 3rd Karmapa Lama]].{{sfn | Oldmeadow | 2001 | p=269}}
[[Giuseppe Tucci]] traced the origin of the tulku concept to [[Vajrayana#History|Indian Vajrayana]], particularly in a fragmentary biography of [[Maitripada]] he discovered in [[Nepal]].{{sfn| Ray | 1986 | p=42}} The tulku system of preserving Dharma lineages developed in Tibet after the 12th century, with the first recognized tulku being perhaps [[Rangjung Dorje, 3rd Karmapa Lama]].{{sfn |Oldmeadow|2001|p=269}} Foreign tulkus have been identified since at least the sixteenth century, when the grandson of the Mongol [[Altan Khan]] was recognized as the [[4th Dalai Lama]]. The [[Buddhism in Mongolia|Mongol conversion to Buddhism]] served a political function and allowed [[Tibet]] to build a closer relationship with the Mongol [[Yuan Dynasty]].{{sfn | Bhushan | Garfield | Zablocki | 2009 | p=45}} Traditionally, however, tulku were only recognized from Tibetan cultural areas, encompassing Tibet, Nepal, [[Mongolia]], and [[Bhutan]].{{sfn | Ary | 2012 | p=398}}
The [[Annexation of Tibet by the People's Republic of China|Chinese annexation of Tibet]] in 1959 created massive social upheaval. This intensified during the [[Cultural Revolution]] which brought irreparable damage to the institutions and traditions which constitute Tibetan Buddhism as one of the [[Four Olds]]. As a result, Tibetan Buddhism has flourished in areas of Tibetan culture not under Chinese rule, such as Nepal, Bhutan, and parts of [[North India]]. In India, the traditional monastic system is largely intact and the tulku system remains politically relevant.{{sfn | Oldmeadow | 2001 | p=266-267}} Compounded with the inherent transnational character of [[proselytization|proselytizing]] religions, Tibetan Buddhism is "pulled between the need to adapt itself and the need to preserve itself".{{sfn | Bhushan | Garfield | Zablocki | 2009 | p=44}}
[[Buddhism in the West|Westerners]] began taking an interest in Tibetan Buddhism during the [[1960s counterculture|counterculture]] of the 1960s, and Tibetan Buddhism became popular among western Buddhists and they began to be recognized as incarnations of Buddhist masters around this time.{{sfn|Nattier|1995}}{{sfn | Oldmeadow | 2001 | p=267}} Most of these, however, were [[expatriate]] Tibetans or Tibetans of [[Mixed race|mixed heritage]], such as the son of [[Chögyam Trungpa]]. Initially, Westerners were not recognized as tulkus by the wider Tibetan diaspora.{{sfn | deJong | 1974 | pp=55–106}}{{sfn|Ary|2012|p=410}}
The recognition of Westerners as tulkus began in the 1970s, following the spread of Tibetan Buddhism to modern Western countries such as the [[United States]].{{sfn|Ary|2012|pp=398–427}}{{sfn|Atay|D'Silva|2019|p=222}}{{sfn|Moran|2004}}{{sfn|Bhushan|Garfield|Zablocki|2009|}}{{excessive citations inline|date=November 2023}} The first recognized Western tulku was Dylan Henderson, an American boy identified as his father's teacher, or alternatively Ossian MacLise. MacLise, however, was born in [[Kathmandu, Nepal]].{{sfn|Juhasz|Lebow|2015|p=351}}{{sfn|Liechty|2017|pp=364}}
<!-- need to include all the other notable tulku lineages in historical order here -->
===Lineage of the Karmapas===
{{further|Karmapa|Karmapa controversy}}
[[Image:Karmapa2.jpg|upright|thumb|left|The second Karmapa was the first tulku.]]
[[Düsum Khyenpa, 1st Karmapa Lama]] ({{bo|w=Dus gsum Mkhyen pa}}, 1110–1193), was a disciple of the Tibetan master [[Gampopa]]. A talented child who studied Buddhism with his father from an early age and who sought out great teachers in his twenties and thirties, he is said to have attained [[bodhi|enlightenment]] at the age of fifty while practicing [[dream yoga]]. He was henceforth regarded by the contemporary highly respected masters Shakya Śri and Lama Shang as the Karmapa, a manifestation of [[Avalokiteśvara]], whose coming was predicted in the ''[[Samadhiraja Sutra]]''{{sfn|Thrangu Rinpoche|1993}} and the ''[[Laṅkāvatāra Sūtra]]''.<ref>[http://www.buddhistinformation.com/lankavatara_sutra.htm The Lankavatara Sutra] {{webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20060113184106/http://www.buddhistinformation.com/lankavatara_sutra.htm |date=2006-01-13 }}</ref>
The Karmapa is a long line of consciously reborn lamas. A Karmapa's identity is confirmed through a combination realized [[lama|lineage teachers]] supernatural insight, prediction letters left by the previous Karmapa, and the young child's own self-proclamation and ability to identify objects and people known to its previous incarnation.{{sfn|Karma Thinley Rinpoche|1980 |pp=44,81,89,95,109,110,113,115,119,121,125,129}}{{sfn|Levin|2013|p=xx}}
After the [[first Karmapa]] died in 1193, a lama had recurrent visions of a particular child as his [[Rebirth (Buddhism)|rebirth]]. This child (born {{Circa|1205}}) was recognized as the [[Karma Pakshi, 2nd Karmapa Lama]] (1204–1283), thus beginning the Tibetan tulku tradition. Karma Pakshi was the first recognized tulku in [[Tibetan Buddhism]] that predicted the circumstances of his rebirth.{{sfn|Melnick|2007}}{{sfn|Wong|2010|p=2}}
The 8th, 10th, and 12th incarnations, as well as the [[Rangjung Rigpe Dorje, 16th Karmapa#Controversy and Recognition as Karmapa|16th Karmapa]], each faced conflicts during their recognition,{{sfn|Thrangu Rinpoche|n.d.}} which were ultimately resolved. There was a [[Karmapa controversy|controversy]] over the enthronement of two 17th Karmapas.
=== Lineage of the Dalai Lamas===
{{main|Dalai Lama}}
[[File:Tsongkapa, thangka from Tibet in the 15th-century, painting on cloth - Google Art Project.jpg|thumb|Tsongkapa, 15th-century painting, [[Rubin Museum of Art]] ]]
Gendun Drup (1391–1474), a disciple of the founder [[Je Tsongkhapa|Je Tsongkapa]],<ref name="陈庆英2005_p15">{{cite book|author=陈庆英|title=达赖喇嘛转世及历史定制英|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=haMIsdC3iZwC&pg=PA15|year=2005|publisher=五洲传播出版社|isbn=978-7-5085-0745-3|pages=16–}}</ref> was the ordination name of the monk who came to be known as the '[[First Dalai Lama]]', but only from 104 years after he died.{{sfn|Richardson|1984|pp=40–41}} There had been resistance, since first he was ordained a monk in the Kadampa tradition{{sfn|Shakabpa|1967|p={{page needed|date=November 2023}}}} and for various reasons, for hundreds of years the Kadampa school had eschewed the adoption of the ''tulku'' system to which the older schools adhered.{{sfn|Mullin|2001|p=87}} [[Tsongkhapa]] largely modelled his new, reformed [[Gelugpa]] school on the Kadampa tradition and refrained from starting a tulku system.{{sfn|Mullin|2001|pp=94–95}} Therefore, although Gendun Drup grew to be a very important Gelugpa lama, after he died in 1474 there was no question of any search being made to identify his incarnation.{{sfn|Mullin|2001|p=87}}
Despite this, when the Tashilhunpo monks started hearing what seemed credible accounts that an incarnation of Gendun Drup had appeared nearby and repeatedly announced himself from the age of two, their curiosity was aroused.{{sfn|Mullin|2001|pp=90–95}} It was some 55 years after Tsongkhapa's death when eventually, the monastic authorities saw compelling evidence that convinced them the child in question was indeed the incarnation of their founder. They felt obliged to break with their own tradition and in 1487, the boy was renamed [[Gendun Gyatso]] and installed at Tashilhunpo as Gendun Drup's tulku, albeit informally.{{sfn|Mullin|2001|pp=95–96}}
Gendun Gyatso died in 1542 and the lineage of Dalai Lama tulkus finally became firmly established when the third incarnation, [[3rd Dalai Lama|Sonam Gyatso]] (1543–1588), came forth. He made himself known as the ''tulku'' of Gendun Gyatso and was formally recognised and enthroned at Drepung in 1546.{{sfn|Mullin|2001|pp=137–8}} When Gendun Gyatso was given the titular name "Dalai Lama" by the Tümed [[Altan Khan]] in 1578,{{sfn|Tagliacozzo|2015|p=[https://books.google.com/books?id=rKLrBQAAQBAJ&pg=PT153 153]}} his two predecessors were accorded the title posthumously and he became known as the third in the lineage.{{sfn|Richardson|1984|pp=40–41}}
=== Lineage of the Tai Situpas ===
{{main|Tai Situpa}}
[[File:Tai Situ Rinpoche Thankha.jpeg|upright|thumb|''[[Thangka]]'' of Tai Situ]]
The [[Tai Situpa]] lineage is one of the oldest tulku lineages in the [[Kagyu]] school of [[Tibetan Buddhism]]<ref name="palpung">[http://www.palpung.com/rinpoche.php History of the Tai Situpas]</ref> In Tibetan Buddhism tradition, Kenting Tai Situpa is considered as emanation of Bodhisattva [[Maitreya]] and [[Padmasambhava]] and who has been incarnated numerous times as [[India]]n and [[Tibet]]an [[yogi]]s since the time of the [[Gautama Buddha|historical Buddha]].<ref name="palpung" />
[[Chokyi Gyaltsen]] was the first to bear the title "Grand [[Situ (office)|Situ]]" ({{zh |c = 大司徒 |p = Dà Sītú }}), conferred upon him in 1407 by the [[Yongle Emperor]] of [[Ming dynasty|Ming China]]. He was a close disciple of [[Deshin Shekpa, 5th Karmapa Lama]], who appointed him [[abbot]] of Karma Goen, the Karmapa's principal [[monastery]] at the time. The full title bestowed was ''Kenting Naya Tang Nyontse Geshetse Tai Situpa'' which is shortened to ''Kenting Tai Situ''. The full title means "far reaching, unshakable, great master, holder of the command".{{sfn|Hollmann|2006}}
The current Tai Situpa, [[Pema Tönyö Nyinje]], is the 12th.{{sfn|Jamgon Kongtrul|1997|p=166}} He is the head of [[Palpung Monastery]].
===Lineage of Samding Dorje Phagmo===
{{main|Samding Dorje Phagmo}}
[[File:Dorje Phagmo incarnation in 16th century mural at Myemo Chekar.png|upright|thumb|left|Mural depiction of [[Chökyi Drönma]], the first incarnation of Samding Dorje Phagmo, at [[Nyêmo Chekar monastery]] ]]
The [[Samding Dorje Phagmo]] ({{bo|t=བསམ་སྡིང་རྡོ་རྗེ་ཕག་མོ}}) is the highest female tulku in Tibet{{sfn|Dowman|1988|p=268}} and the third highest-ranking person in the hierarchy after the [[Dalai Lama]] and the [[Panchen Lama]].{{sfn|Mullin|2001|p=175}} She was listed among the highest-ranking reincarnations at the time of the [[5th Dalai Lama]], recognized by the Tibetan government and acknowledged by the emperors of [[Qing dynasty|Qing China]].{{sfn|Diemberger|2007|p=2}} In her first incarnation, as [[Chökyi Drönma]] (1422–1455 [[Common Era|CE]]), she was the student and consort of the famous polymath [[Thang Tong Gyalpo]],{{sfn|Stearns|2007|p=4ff}} who first identified her as an emanation of [[Vajravārāhī]],{{sfn|Diemberger|2007|p= 46–47}} and the consort of Bodong Panchen.{{sfn|Stearns|2007|p=554, n.837}} The seat of the Samding Dorje Phagmo is at [[Samding Monastery]], in Tibet.
The current (12th) Samding Dorje Pakmo Trülku is Dechen Chökyi Drönma, who was born in 1938 or 1942. Dechen Chökyi Drönma was very young at the [[Incorporation of Tibet into the People's Republic of China|time of the Chinese occupation]], and her exact date of birth is contested.{{sfn|Diemberger|2007|p=299–300}} Dechen Chökyi Drönma was recognised by the present [[14th Dalai Lama]] as a true incarnation and served as a vice president of the [[Buddhist Association of China]] in 1956 while he was president, and [[Choekyi Gyaltsen, 10th Panchen Lama]] also as vice president. She went to Lhasa in 1958 and received the empowerment of [[Yamantaka]] from the Dalai Lama and the empowerment of [[Vajrayogini]] from the Dalai Lama's tutor, [[Trijang Lobsang Yeshe Tenzin Gyatso]].{{sfn|Diemberger|2007|p=302-303}} She has been trained in the Bodongpa tradition and remains the head of the [[Samding Monastery]]. She simultaneously holds the post of a high government cadre in the [[Tibet Autonomous Region]]. She has as a result been accused of collaborating with the Chinese.{{sfn|French|2003|p=220}}{{sfn|Willis|1984|p=20}}
{{clear}}
===Lineage of the Trungpa tülkus===
{{main|Trungpa tülkus}}
[[File:Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche.jpg|thumb|Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche, the 11th Trungpa tülku]]
The Trungpa tülkus are a line of incarnate [[Tibet]]an [[lama]]s who traditionally head Surmang monastery complex in [[Kham]], now [[Surmang]]. There have been twelve such Trungpa tulkus. They are members of the [[Karma Kagyu]] tradition as well as the [[Nyingma]] tradition. These tulkus are recognized as reincarnations of Künga Gyaltsen (15th century), a student of Trungmase.
The 11th Trungpa tulku was [[Chögyam Trungpa]] (1940–1987). He was one of the most influential teachers of [[Buddhism in the West]] and founded [[Shambhala Buddhism]].
[[Choseng Trungpa]] Rinpoche is the 12th and current Trungpa tulku.{{sfn|Midal|2005|p=18}}
===Lineage of the Zhabdrung Rinpoches===
In [[Bhutan]], the title Zhabdrung Rinpoche refers to [[Ngawang Namgyal]] (1594–1651), the founder of the Bhutanese state, or one of his successive [[reincarnation]]s. Following his death, the ruling authorities in Bhutan were faced with the problem of succession. To neutralize the power of future Zhabdrung incarnations, the Druk Desi, Je Khenpo and penlops conspired to recognize not a single person but rather as three separate persons—a ''body incarnation'' (''Ku tulku''), a ''mind incarnation'' (''Thu tulku'' or ''Thugtrul''), and a ''speech incarnation'' (''Sung tulku'' or ''Sungtrul''). In spite of their efforts to consolidate the power established by the original Zhabdrung, the country sank into warring factionalism for the next 200 years. The body incarnation lineage died out in the mid-18th century, while the mind and speech incarnations of the Zhabdrung continued into the 20th century. The mind incarnation was the one generally recognized as the ''Zhabdrung''.{{sfn|Rose|1977|pp=26–28}}
Besides the mind incarnation, there was also a line of claimants for the speech incarnation.  At the time the monarchy was founded in 1907, Choley Yeshe Ngodub (or Chogley Yeshey Ngodrup) was the speech incarnation and also served as the last Druk Desi. After his death in 1917, he was succeeded by Chogley Jigme Tenzin (1919–1949).{{sfn|Dorji|Wangchuck|1999|p=13}} The next claimant, unrecognized by the Bhutan government, lived at [[Tawang district#Tawang Monastery|Tawang monastery]] in India and was evacuated to the western Himalayas during the 1962 [[Sino-Indian War]].{{sfn|Rose|1977|p=28}}
Another line of claimants to be the mind incarnation of Ngawang Namgyal existed in Tibet, and was represented by [[Namkhai Norbu]], who lived in Italy.
===Lineage of the Panchen Lamas===
{{main|Panchen Lama}}
[[File:Khedrup Je.jpg|thumb|[[Khedrup Gelek Pelzang, 1st Panchen Lama]]]]
The recognition of Panchen Lamas began with [[Lobsang Chökyi Gyaltsen]], tutor of the [[5th Dalai Lama]], who received the title "Panchen Bogd" from [[Altan Khan]] and the Dalai Lama in 1645.{{Sfn|Chuluun|Bulag|2013|p=17}} ''Bogd'' is Mongolian, meaning "holy".{{sfn|Lessing|1960}} [[Khedrup Gelek Pelzang]], [[Sönam Choklang]] and [[Ensapa Lobsang Döndrup]] were subsequently recognized as the first to third Panchen Lamas posthumously.
In 1713, the [[Kangxi Emperor]] of the [[Qing dynasty]] granted the title ''Panchen Erdeni'' to the [[5th Panchen Lama]]. In 1792, the [[Qianlong Emperor]] issued a decree known as the [[29-Article Ordinance for the More Effective Governing of Tibet]], and Article One of the decree was designed to be used in the selection of rinpoches, lamas and other high offices within Tibetan Buddhism, including the Dalai Lamas, Panchen Lamas and Mongolian lamas.<ref>{{cite web |title=Reincarnation |url=http://www.dalailama.com/messages/statement-of-his-holiness-the-fourteenth-dalai-lama-tenzin-gyatso-on-the-issue-of-his-reincarnation |publisher=[[14th Dalai Lama]] |date=September 24, 2011 |access-date=December 17, 2015}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |url=http://eng.tibet.cn/culture/tibetan_buddhism/1449128868125.shtml |title=Origin of "drawing lots from the golden urn"_Tibetan Buddhism_TIBET |website=eng.tibet.cn |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20180401004649/http://eng.tibet.cn/culture/tibetan_buddhism/1449128868125.shtml |archive-date=2018-04-01}}</ref>
Traditionally, the Panchen Lama is the head of [[Tashilhunpo Monastery]], and holds religious and secular power over the [[Ü-Tsang|Tsang]] region centered in [[Shigatse]], independent of the [[Ganden Podrang]] authority led by the Dalai Lama.{{sfn|Goldstein|2007|p=[https://archive.org/details/historyofmodernt00melv/page/267 267]}}{{sfn|Goldstein|Sherap|Siebenschuh|2004|p=[https://archive.org/details/tibetanrevolutio0000gold/page/161 161]}} The Dalai Lama and Panchen Lama are closely connected, and each participates in the process of recognizing the other's reincarnations.<ref name="choosing">{{cite news |url=http://www.economist.com/node/21526388 |title=China, Tibet and the Dalai Lama |newspaper=[[The Economist]]}}</ref>
The current 11th Panchen Lama, [[Gedhun Choekyi Nyima]], was recognized by the [[14th Dalai Lama]] on 14 May 1995. Three days later, the six-year-old Panchen Lama was kidnapped by the Chinese government and his family was taken into custody. The Chinese government instead named [[Gyaincain Norbu]] as the 11th Panchen Lama. Their nomination has been [[11th Panchen Lama controversy|widely rejected]] by Buddhists in Tibet and abroad, while governments have called for information about and the release of the Panchen Lama. Gedhun Choekyi Nyima has never been publicly seen since 1995.<ref name="secret">{{cite news |url=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/dorjee-tseten/chinas-worst-kept-secret-_b_7308598.html |title=China's Worst Kept Secret: 5 Facts About the Abduction of Tibet's Panchen Lama |work=[[HuffPost]]}}</ref><ref name="fake">{{cite news |url=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/sep/06/china-says-panchen-lama-living-a-normal-life-20-years-after-disappearance |title=China says Panchen Lama 'living a normal life' 20 years after disappearance |date=September 6, 2015 |access-date=June 24, 2008 |newspaper=[[The Guardian]] |location=London}}</ref>
=== Lineage of Genyenma Ahkon Lhamo ===
The first Genyenma Ahkon Lhamo, a meditator recognized as a wisdom dakini{{sfn|Zangpo|1988|p=186}} was one of the main disciples of [[Namchö Mingyur Dorje]] (1645–1667){{sfn|Zangpo|1988|p=186}} and sister of Rigdzin Kunzang Sherab, Migyur Dorje's Dharma heir{{sfn|Zangpo|1988|p=62}} and the First Throneholder of [[Palyul]] Monastery (founded 1665).{{sfn|Mackenzie|1996|pp=61–5}} She was credited as being instrumental to the founding of Palyul (now one of the Nyingma's six main or "mother" monasteries{{sfn|Zangpo|1988|p=9}}) and for leaving a relic that is important to Palyul. During the cremation of her body, her kapala (top half of the skull) is said to have flown three kilometers and come to rest at the foot of the teaching throne of her brother. Found to be miraculously embossed with the sacred syllable AH, the kapala became an important relic housed at Palyul monastery in Tibet.{{sfn|Zangpo|1988|p=186}}
[[File:Jetsunma akhon lhamo enthronement 1998.jpg|thumb|Western tulku [[Jetsunma Ahkon Lhamo]] during her enthronement]]
The Third Drubwang [[Penor Rinpoche|Padma Norbu ("Penor") Rinpoche]], 11th Throneholder of Palyul Monastery, former Supreme Head of the [[Nyingma]] tradition{{sfn|Sherrill|2000|p=7}} was recognized as a tulku and brought to Palyul Monastery in 1936 at the age of four. He recounted that as a young tulku in Tibet, inspired by seeing the skull relic, he made prayers to find Ahkon Lhamo's incarnation.{{sfn|Zangpo|1988|p=186}}{{sfn|Sherrill|2000|p=135}} Though most of the kapala relic was pulverized into dust during the [[Cultural Revolution]], one Tibetan man managed to save a silver dollar-size piece on which the syllable "AH" appears. Penor Rinpoche acquired it from him on a return trip to Tibet in 1987. He had it preserved in a crystal lotus bowl.
In 1987, Penor Rinpoche officially recognized Alyce Louise Zeoli as the tulku of Genyenma Ahkon Lhamo during her visit to his Namdroling Monastery in [[Bylakuppe]], [[Karnataka]], India.<ref>{{cite magazine |title=American-born Woman Tulku Enthroned |magazine=Vajradhatu Sun |date=October–November 1988}}{{full citation needed|date=November 2023}}</ref> He gave her the crystal lotus bowl containing the relic of Ahkon Lhamo just prior to the occasion of her enthronement ceremony as [[Jetsunma Ahkon Lhamo]] at [[Kunzang Palyul Choling]] (KPC) in 1988.{{sfn|Mackenzie|1996|p=76}} The relic remains at KPC and is displayed on auspicious days.
===Lineage of Jamgon Kongtrul===
{{main|Jamgon Kongtrul}}
[[File:Lodro Thaye.jpg|upright|thumb|right|Jamgön Kongtrül Lodrö Thayé]]
Kongtrul tulkus are the main custodians of [[Jamgon Kongtrul]] (1813–1899). Jamgön Kongtrül Lodrö Thayé was a Tibetan Buddhist scholar, poet, artist, physician, [[tertön]] and polymath.{{sfn|Jackson|2012}}{{sfn|Ringu Tulku|2007}} He is credited as one of the founders of the [[Rimé movement]] (non-sectarian), compiling what is known as the "Five Great Treasuries".{{sfn|Jamgon Kongtrul|2003|loc=Translators' Introduction}} He achieved great renown as a scholar and writer, especially among the [[Nyingma]] and [[Kagyu]] lineages and composed over 90 volumes of Buddhist writing,{{sfn|Jackson|2012}}{{sfn|Jamgon Kongtrul|2003|loc=Translators' Introduction}} including his magnum opus, ''[[Sheja Dzö|The Treasury of Knowledge]]''. There have been several recognized tulkus of Lodro Thaye.
The current lineage holder as the 4th Jamgon Kongtrul is [[Lodrö Chökyi Nyima]]. He was recognized in August 1996 by [[Ogyen Trinley Dorje]], the 17th [[Karmapa]], who gave the name Jamgon Lodro Chokyi Nyima Dronme Chok Thamced Le Nampar Gyalwe De. He was born on November{{nbsp}}26, 1995, in [[Qüxü County|Chushur Dzong]], near Chushur Dzong, in Central Tibet. This recognition was confirmed by the [[14th Dalai Lama]], [[Sakya Trizin]], head of the [[Sakya (Tibetan Buddhist school)|Sakya]] school of [[Tibetan Buddhism]], and [[Mindroling Trichen]], former head of the [[Nyingma]] tradition. All three performed hair-cutting ceremonies and bestowed names, as is traditional. As the reincarnation of Jamgon Kongtrul, Lodrö is entitled to be called "[[Rinpoche]]".
===Lineage of Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo===
{{main|Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo}}
[[File:Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo.jpg|thumb|Painting of Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo]]
Khyentse tulkus are the main custodians of the lineage of [[Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo]] (1820–1892), a teacher, scholar and [[tertön]] of 19th-century [[Tibet]]. He was a leading figure in the [[Rimé movement]].
Several tulkus of Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo, including those of body ''(sku)'', speech ''(gsung)'', mind ''(thugs)'', qualities ''(yon tan)'' and activity ''({{bo|w='phrin las}})'', were recognized in Tibet.{{sfn|Orgyen Tobgyal Rinpoche|1996}} Of these, the body incarnation was Dzongsar Khyentse Jamyang Chökyi Wangpo, who was enthroned at Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo's main seat at [[Dzongsar Monastery]] but died in an accident c. 1909.{{sfn|Smith|2001|p=268}} The activity incarnation [[Dzongsar Khyentse Chökyi Lodrö]], who was originally enthroned at [[Katok Monastery]] succeeded him. The speech incarnation was the [[Second Beru Khyentse]] and the mind incarnation [[Dilgo Khyentse]]. Since the early 1960s, Dilgo Khyentse, single-handedly upholding the unique tradition of Khyentse incarnations, propagated Buddhism tirelessly in India, Bhutan, Nepal, [[Tibet]], and the West.{{sfn|Thondup|1996|p=221}}
{{expand section|date=January 2024}}
{{clear}}
===Lineage of Dudjom Lingpa===
{{further|Dudjom Lingpa|Dudjom Jigdral Yeshe Dorje}}
[[File:Dudjom Lingpa.jpg|thumb|Dudjom Lingpa]]
[[Dudjom Lingpa]] (1835–1904) was a Tibetan [[meditation]] master, spiritual teacher and [[tertön]].{{sfn|Dudjom Lingpa|2002|p=xiii}} He stands out from the norm of [[Tibetan Buddhism|Tibetan Buddhist]] teachers in the sense that he had no formal education, nor did he take ordination as a [[monk]] or belong to any established [[Buddhism|Buddhist]] school or tradition of his time.{{sfn|Drolma|2012|p={{page needed|date=July 2021}}}}
His recognized successor, [[Kyabje Dudjom Jigdral Yeshe Dorje]], was more commonly known as Dudjom Rinpoche (1904–1987).<ref name=Wogmin>{{cite web |title=His Holiness Dudjom Rinpoche: Upasaka Vidyadhara Jigdrel Yeshe Dorje (1904–1987) |url=http://www.dharma-media.org/wogmin/dudjom.html |access-date=2021-01-15 |website=Drikung Kagyu Buddhist Monastery, Wogmin Thubten Shedrup Ling |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20181021232748/https://www.dharma-media.org/wogmin/dudjom.html |archive-date=2018-10-21}}</ref> He is considered to be the direct incarnation of Dudjom Lingpa.<ref name=Wogmin/> He was a [[Nyingma]] [[Householder (Buddhism)|householder]], yogi, and a [[Vajrayana]] and [[Dzogchen]] master. According to his disciple Khenpo Tsewang Dongyal, he was revered as "His Holiness" and as a "Master of Masters".{{sfn|Dongyal|2008|p={{page needed|date=November 2023}}}}
The third Dudjom tulku, Sangye Pema Zhepa, was first recognized by terton Khandro Tare Lama through a prophetic poem written in [[dakini script]] on the day of his birth. Tare Lama wrote to [[Chatral Rinpoche]], who confirmed the prophecy and recognized the three-year-old tulku in person. Recognitions were also conferred by the [[14th Dalai Lama]], [[Penor Rinpoche|Kyabje Penor Rinpoche]], [[Sakya Trizin|Sakya Trinzin Rinpoche]], and others.<ref>{{cite magazine |date=Spring 1993 |title=Khyabje Dudjom Rinpoche to be Enthroned |magazine=Snow Lion Newsletter and Catalog |page=2 |url=https://www.shambhala.com/snowlion_articles/khyabje-dudjom-rinpoche-to-be-enthroned/ |access-date=2023-11-04 |via=Shambhala.com}}</ref> On February 15, 2022, Dudjom Rinpoche Sangye Pema Zhepa, after telling his staff that he was going to rest and relax, suddenly died. He was 32 years of age when he passed at the Dudjom Labrang, his residence.{{sfn|Panzica|2022}}{{sfn|Lewis|2022}}
===Lineage of Thubten Yeshe===
{{main|Thubten Yeshe}}
[[Thubten Yeshe]] (1935–1984) was a [[Tibet]]an [[lama]] who, while exiled in [[Nepal]], co-founded [[Kopan Monastery]] (1969) and the [[Foundation for the Preservation of the Mahayana Tradition]] (1975). He followed the [[Gelug]] tradition, and was considered unconventional in his teaching style. Lama Yeshe died in 1984, 20 minutes before dawn on the first day of [[Losar]], the Tibetan New Year. His body was cremated at the Vajrapani Institute in [[Boulder Creek, California]],{{sfn|Zopa Rinpoche|2009}} where there is a [[stupa]] honoring him.
[[File:Tenzin Osel Hita, IVY, 191227 by Anouk Burel.jpeg|150px|thumb|[[Tenzin Ösel Hita]] in 2018]]
In 1986, after certain traditional tests, the [[14th Dalai Lama|Dalai Lama]] formally recognized [[Tenzin Ösel Hita]] as the ''tulku'' or [[reincarnation]] of [[Thubten Yeshe]]—making him one of only a handful of Western tulkus—and renamed him "Tenzin Ösel Rinpoche" ({{bo|t=བསྟན་འཛིན་འོད་གསལ་རིན་པོ་ཆེ།}}). This makes Thubten Yeshe the first in a new lineage of tulkus. As a child Ösel was heavily promoted by the FPMT, and made the subject of a book by [[Vicki Mackenzie]], ''Reincarnation: The Boy Lama''.{{sfn|Mackenzie|1996}} He is the fifth of nine siblings.{{sfn|Mackenzie|1996}}
==Process==
===Finding a successor===
Pamela Logan outlines a general approach for finding a successor:
{{blockquote|When an old tulku dies, a committee of senior lamas convenes to find the young reincarnation. The group may employ a number of methods in their search. First, they will probably look for a letter left behind by the departed tulku indicating where he intends to be born again. They will ask the close friends of the departed to recall everything he said during his last days, in case he may have given hints. Often, an oracle is consulted. Sometimes a prominent lama has a dream that reveals details of the child's house, parents, or of geographical features near his home. Sometimes heaven presents a sign, perhaps a rainbow, leading the search party to the child.{{sfn|Logan|2004}} }}
===Training===
Logan describes the training a tulku undergoes from a young age:
{{blockquote|He is brought up inside a monastery, under the direction of a head tutor and a number of other teachers or servants. He must study hard and adhere to a strict regimen. He has few if any toys or playmates, and is rarely allowed outside. Early on, he learns to receive important visitors, take part in complicated rituals, and give blessings to followers and pilgrims. Sometimes one or both parents are allowed to live near the young tulku. Older brothers are sometimes inducted into the monastery as monk-companions for the holy child. Yet his elderly tutors are the most influential people in his life, and they become his de facto parents.{{sfn|Logan|2004}} }}
The academic atmosphere is balanced by unconditional love:
{{blockquote|Countering the bleak academic regimen is an atmosphere of overwhelming, unconditional love. During the tulku's every waking moment, monks, family members, and awed, adoring visitors, shower the youth with love.
If you visit a child tulku, you will probably notice that his quarters are pervaded by a wonderful glow. Everyone beams at the tulku. The tulku beams back. If he asks for something, he is given it immediately, and if he errs, he is corrected just as immediately. Western visitors to the young 14th Dalai Lama commented on "the extraordinary steadiness of his gaze." Even when quite young, the boys have remarkable poise; they sit calmly without fidgeting, even through ceremonies that may last all day.{{sfn|Logan|2004}} }}
== Analysis and criticism ==
According to [[Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse Rinpoche]], the tulku system is a method of identifying and nurturing spiritual talent, ensuring the continuity of the tradition, and controlling resources and revenue streams. He describes how the system also ensured control of valuable real estate and financial capital, making Tibetan monasteries early examples of capitalistic institutions.{{sfn|McLeod|2016}} In an analysis of an article titled "Time for Radical Change in How We Raise Our Tulkus" by Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse Rinpoche,{{sfn|Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse Rinpoche|2016}} Ken McLeod relates that the tulku system is facing challenges in the modern world. Tulkus can no longer be secluded during training as they were in Tibet, and their roles are changing. There is a shift from the traditional three-year retreat, and the adoption of titles like "His Holiness" has become a competition among tulku lineages to establish pedigree.{{sfn|McLeod|2016}}
The tulku system has been criticized since its inception. In the centuries following the inception of the system used to identify reincarnate lamas, the process became increasingly corrupted and politicized by those living outside monastic-ordination systems, as the process also led indirectly to sources of material wealth and power in Tibet.{{efn|{{harvnb|McKay|2003|p=237}}: "Ordinarily the rebirth is found by the oracular prediction of some local lama of repute when in a state of trance. Corruption is general and a large proportion of reincarnations are members of noble or wealthy families. [...] The multiplication of reincarnations seems to be a development due to motives very similar to those which in the middle ages filled our abbeys and cathedrals with the bodies and relics of saints. A reincarnation is a valuable asset to any lamasery on account of the offerings which his holiness attracts, and it is a great temptation to a poor lamasery to magnify the merits of one of its learned monks in order to justify a search for his reimbodiment. The longer the series of reincarnations the more holy the saint becomes."}}{{efn|{{harvnb|Curren|2006|pp=4–5}}: "Outsiders might think that tulkus were always chosen according to set procedures laid down to ensure the accuracy of the result-that the child located would be the genuine reincarnation of the dead master, as in the scene from the movie Kundun. But in Tibetan history, tulku searches were not always conducted in such a pure way. Because reincarnating lamas inherited great wealth and power from their predecessors they became the center of many political disputes. <br />"Tulkus were often recognized based on non-religious factors. Sometimes monastic officials wanted a child from a powerful local noble family to give their cloister more political clout. Other times, they wanted a child from a lower-class family that would have little leverage to influence the child's upbringing. In yet other situations, the desires of the monastic officials took second place to external politics. A local warlord, the Chinese emperor, or even the Dalai Lama's government in Lhasa might try to impose its choice of tulku on a monastery for political reasons."}}{{efn|{{harvnb|Samuel|1993|p=285}}: "Disputes over the recognition of trulku are not uncommon, and Tibetans are well aware of the possibility of fraud. In the premodern period, wealthy estates were frequently at issue in such cases and for a family to have its child recognized as a major trulku made a dramatic difference to the family's status and resources."}}{{efn|{{harvnb|Thondup|2011|p={{page needed|date=December 2023}}}}: "The main cause of corruption, however, is not the lack of merit of the tulku tradition in general or the lack of enlightened lamas who are able to recognize them. Rather, it is the greed for material or social gain that drives the parents, relatives, or other interested people to fabricate stories and manipulate the process in favor of their own candidate. In the past, institutions such as monasteries and nunneries mostly maintained strict and vigilant safeguards against such improper influences. But today, in many cases, the institutions themselves are powerless at best."}} Highly respected teachers like the [[14th Dalai Lama]] and [[Shamar Rinpoche]] have bemoaned the practice as belonging to feudal times, and have advocated revamping the system in way that divorces the reincarnate teacher from administrative politics and allows them to distinguish themselves.{{efn|{{harvnb|Puri|2019}}: "'Institutions need to be owned by the people, not by an individual. Like my own institution, the Dalai Lama's office, I feel it is linked to a feudal system. In 1969, in one my official statements, I had mentioned it should continue... But now I feel, not necessarily. It should go. I feel it should not be concentrated in a few people only (Tibetans)', he said."}}{{efn|{{harvnb|Curren|2006|p=254}}: "Surprisingly, considering that Tibetans believe him to be a high tulku himself, Shamar is one of the loudest critics of filling leadership positions in Tibetan Buddhism with reincarnate lamas. 'I have criticized Tibetan monastery administration since I was a boy at Rumtek', Shamar told me. 'Choosing tulkus has always been political. Now, this is becoming painfully clear to all. Tulkus are just bodhisattvas. They can reincarnate as humans, but also as fish or birds, for example. They do not need to be recognized officially to do their work to help sentient beings. I pray that bodhisattvas will continue to help our world. But we do not need to make them our administrative leaders. This just leads to too many fake tulkus and cheapens both religion and politics. We should slowly work to abandon this system and begin choosing leading lamas on the basis of their merit.'<br />"Shamar believes that lamas who serve as leaders of Buddhist schools or powerful monasteries should be elected by their peers, as in the case of the head lama of Bhutan, known as the Je Khenpo, or the Ganden Tripa of the Gelugpas. Both of these positions are filled by older, experienced lamas who serve a term as leader after being selected by a qualified group of other high lamas. 'They are not treated like gods, but merely respected as experienced elders', Shamar said."}}{{efn|{{harvnb|Frayer|2019}}: "According to Tibetan Buddhist belief, he has control over his reincarnation: 'The person who reincarnates has sole legitimate authority over where and how he or she takes rebirth', according to the Dalai Lama's official website, 'and how that reincarnation is to be recognized'."}}{{efn|{{harvnb|Terhune|2004|p=141}}: "The record of the Dalai Lamas reveals one ambitious power struggle after another, frequently orchestrated by ministers or regents keen to hang onto their authority. Influential monks were often similarly well connected. Certain aristocratic or otherwise important families generated a suspicious abundance of consequential lamas. Tulkus meant power in a theocracy. While most incarnate lamas are revered as sincere, spiritual figures, these holy individuals can also be exploited by ambitious persons in their entourage. Even strong lamas are not immune to manipulation by people in their families or monasteries. Lamas who cite flaws in the tulku system—including the current Dalai Lama—point out that if a halfway intelligent child is plucked from poverty and oblivion and given every advantage and education, he is likely to make something of himself. And if a child is truly extraordinary, he will naturally distinguish himself."}}
Criticism has also been directed against individual tulkus, including both Tibetan and [[Western tulku]]s.{{sfn|Lachs|2019}} The validity of the recognition of Tsangyang Gyatso (born 1683) as the [[6th Dalai Lama]] in 1697 was questioned{{sfn|Lhundrub Dargye|2011|p=xl}} due to the fact that he preferred a libertine lifestyle to that of an ordained monk. Living as a ''[[ngagpa]]'' (lay practitioner and yogi), he grew his hair long, dressed as a regular Tibetan, and was said to drink alcohol and enjoy the company of women.{{sfn|Cordier|Pelliot|1922|p=[https://archive.org/stream/s2tungpaotoungp11corduoft#page/30/mode/2up 30]}}
[[Chögyam Trungpa]], the 11th [[Trungpa tulku]], was criticized for his unconventional teaching style,{{sfn|Midal|2005|p=160}} for his sexual involvement with a number of his female students,{{sfn|Remski|2021}} and for smoking tobacco and liberally using alcohol; many who knew him characterized him as an alcoholic.{{sfn|Coleman|2001|p=74}}{{sfn|Bhagavan Das|1997|p=251}} The case of Trungpa has been used as an example in calls to reform the tulku system.{{sfn|Lachs|2019}}
The enthronement of [[Steven Seagal]] in 1997 prompted debate. [[Penor Rinpoche]], who has recognized several Western tulku, defended his recognition of Seagal, arguing that it was not uncommon to recognize tulku late in life or for there to exist large gaps between incarnations of a tulku.{{sfn|Penor Rinpoche|1999}} Seagal is involved in the international arms trade and the government of [[Russia]], which has prompted criticism of his title by English journalist [[Marina Hyde]].{{sfn|Hyde|2015}}
Tibetan tulku [[Sogyal Rinpoche]], recognized as an incarnation of 19th-century Tibetan master and visionary [[Tertön Sogyal Lerab Lingpa]], was accused of sexual and physical assault and abuse,{{sfn|Lachs|2019}} as well as misusing charitable funds, with allegations stretching back to the 1970s.{{sfn|Brown|1995}}{{sfn|Brown|2017}} In 2017 his organisation, [[Rigpa (organization)|Rigpa]], announced these allegations would be investigated by an outside party and on 5 September 2018, Rigpa released an independent report produced by the UK law firm [[Lewis Silkin LLP]], which upheld most of the allegations.<ref>{{Cite web |url=https://www.rigpa.org/independent-investigation-report |title=Independent Investigation Report |website=Rigpa |language=en-US |access-date=2020-02-18}}</ref> The case of Sogyal Rinpoche has been used as an example in calls to reform the tulku system.{{sfn|Lachs|2019}}
[[Penor Rinpoche]] has faced criticism for having officially recognized several [[Western tulku]]s, including accusations of bestowing titles for payment,{{sfn|Lattin|1997}} which he has denied.{{sfn|Penor Rinpoche|1999}} The current [[Dalai Lama]] is uncertain whether the recognition of Western tulkus is beneficial.{{sfn|Ary|2012|p=427}}
==List of tulku lineages==
{{More citations needed|section|date=January 2022}}
This is a '''list of tulku lineages'''. Tibetologist [[Françoise Pommaret]] estimates there are presently approximately 500 tulku lineages found across [[Tibet]], [[Bhutan]], Northern [[India]], [[Nepal]], [[Mongolia]], and the southwest provinces of [[China]].{{sfn|Pommaret|1998|p={{page needed|date=November 2023}}}}
<!-- When editing this list bear in mind that the same notability and verifiability criteria apply here as elsewhere in Wikipedia: entries with no independent sources listed either here or in other Wikipedia articles may not be notable, and are likely to be removed. -->
<!-- alphabetical order-->
*[[Arjia Rinpoche]] (on the 8th incarnation)
*[[Bardor Tulku Rinpoche|Bardor Rinpoche]] (on the 3rd incarnation)
*[[Chagdud Rinpoche]]
*[[Changkya Khutukhtu]]
*[[Drikungpa|Chetsang Rinpoche]]
*[[Chokling Tersar|Chokling tulkus]]
*[[Western tulku|Chungdrag Dorje]]
*[[Drikungpa|Chungtsang Rinpoche]]
*[[Dalai Lama]] ({{bo|w=Tā-la’i Bla-ma}}) (on the 14th incarnation)
*[[Dodrupchen Jigme Trinle Ozer|Dodrupchen tulkus]], the main custodians of [[Longchen Nyingthig]]
*[[Dudjom Rinpoche]]
*[[Dzigar Kongtrul Rinpoche]] (on the 2nd or 3rd incarnation)
*[[Dzogchen Rinpoche]] (on the 7th incarnation)
*[[Dzogchen Ponlop Rinpoche]] (on the 7th incarnation)
*[[Gochen Tulku]]
*[[Goshir Gyaltsab]] (on the 12th incarnation)
*[[Gyalwang Drukpa]] (on the 12th incarnation)
*[[Jamgon Kongtrul]] (on the 4th incarnation, disputed)
*[[Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo]]<!-- I don't know if this lineage has a name, so I have listed it under the name of its most famous tulku -->
*[[Jamyang Shêpa]] (on the 6th incarnation)
*[[Jebtsundamba Khutuktu]] (on the 9th incarnation)
*[[Jetsunma Ahkon Lhamo]]
*[[Ju Mipham]]
*[[Kalu Rinpoche]] (on the 2nd incarnation)
*[[Karma Chagme]] (current is 7th incarnation)
*[[Karmapa]] ({{bo|w=Karma-pa}}) (on the 17th incarnation, disputed)
*[[Khamtrul Rinpoche]]
*[[Khandro Rinpoche]]
*[[Khenpo Shenga]]
*[[Ngawang Jigdral Rinpoche]]
*Pagbalha Hutugtu (on the 11th incarnation, currently [[Pagbalha Geleg Namgyai]]){{sfn|Mackerras|2001|p=[https://books.google.com/books?id=LIdA7f94X_EC&pg=RA2-PA1992 1992]}}
*[[Panchen Lama]] (on the 11th incarnation, disputed, one appointed by the Chinese government)
*[[Nenang Pawo|Pawo]] ({{bo|w=Gnas-nang Dpa’-bo}}) (on the 11th incarnation)
*[[Penor Rinpoche]] (3rd incarnation deceased in 2009)
*[[Reting Rinpoche]] (on the 6th or 7th incarnation, disputed, one appointed by Chinese government)
*[[Samding Dorje Phagmo]] ({{bo|w=Bsam-lding Rdo-rje Phag-mo}}) (on the 12th incarnation, another Dorje Phagmo line in Bhutan)
*[[Shamarpa]] ({{bo|w=Zhwa-dmar-pa}}) (14th incarnation died 2014)
*[[Sogyal Rinpoche]]
*[[Tai Situpa]] ({{bo|w=Tai Si-tu-pa}}) (on the 12th incarnation)
*[[Taktser Rinpoche]] (extinguished in 2008)
*[[Tarthang Tulku]]
*[[Tenzin Delek Rinpoche]]<!-- I don't know if this lineage has a name, so I have listed it under the name of its most famous tulku -->
*[[Thrangu Rinpoche]] (on the 9th incarnation)
*[[Thubten Yeshe]] (on the 2nd incarnation, rejected by current tulku, who is committed to spiritual discovery in a post-modern context)
*[[Traleg Kyabgon Rinpoche]] (on the 10th incarnation){{sfn|Lion's Roar Staff|2015}}
*[[Trungpa]] ({{bo|w=Drung-pa}}) (on the 12th incarnation)
*[[Trungram Gyaltrul Rinpoche]] (on the 4th incarnation)
*[[Tsem Tulku Rinpoche]] ({{bo|w=Tshems Sprul-sku}}; 3rd incarnation died 2019)
*[[Tulku Urgyen Rinpoche]] <!-- I don't know if this lineage has a name, so I have listed it under the name of its most famous tulku --> (on the 2nd incarnation?)
*[[Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche]]
*[[Zhabdrung Rinpoche]] ({{bo|w=Zhabs-drung}}) (on the 14th incarnation)
==See also==
* {{annotated link|Avatar}}
* {{annotated link|Enlightenment in Buddhism|Enlightenment}}
* {{annotated link|Karmapa controversy}}
* {{annotated link|Kumari (children)|Kumari}}
* {{annotated link|My Reincarnation|''My Reincarnation''}}
* {{annotated link|Proselytism}}
* {{annotated link|State Religious Affairs Bureau Order No. 5|Reincarnation Application}}
* {{annotated link|Tulku (film)|''Tulku''}}
* {{annotated link|Unmistaken Child|''Unmistaken Child''}}
==References==
===Notes===
{{notelist}}
===Citations===
{{reflist}}
===Works cited===
{{refbegin|2|indent=yes}}
* {{cite book | last=Ary | first=Elijah | title=Little Buddhas | chapter=The Westernization of Tulkus | publisher=Oxford University Press | date=2012-11-19 | pages=398–427 | isbn=978-0-19-994561-0 | doi=10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199860265.003.0017}}
* {{cite book | last1=Atay | first1=A. | last2=D'Silva | first2=M.U. | title=Mediated Intercultural Communication in a Digital Age | publisher=Taylor & Francis | series=Routledge Research in Communication Studies | year=2019 | isbn=978-1-351-39989-0 | url=https://books.google.com/books?id=nJCKDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT222 | access-date=2023-10-31}}
* {{cite book |author-link=Bhagavan Das (yogi) |author=Bhagavan Das |year=1997 |title=It's Here Now (Are You?) |publisher=Broadway |isbn=0-7679-0008-1}}
* {{cite book | editor-last1=Bhushan | editor-first1=Nalini | editor-last2=Garfield | editor-first2=Jay L. | editor-last3=Zablocki | editor-first3=Abraham | title=TransBuddhism: Transmission, Translation, Transformation | publisher=University of Massachusetts Press | publication-place=Amherst | date=2009 | isbn=978-1-55849-708-5}}
* {{cite book |last=Bishop |first=P. |year=1993 |title=Dreams of Power: Tibetan Buddhism, and the Western Imagination |publisher=Bloomsbury Academic |isbn=978-0485113280 |page=63 |quote="Tibetans recognize at least ''three grades'' of identifiable reincarnated persons, usually known as 'tulku' ..."}}
* {{cite news |title=The Precious One |last=Brown |first=Mick |date=2 February 1995 |work=The Telegraph}}
* {{cite news |url=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/thinking-man/sexual-assaults-violent-rages-inside-dark-world-buddhist-teacher/ |title=Sexual assaults and violent rages... Inside the dark world of Buddhist teacher Sogyal Rinpoche |last=Brown |first=Mick |date=21 September 2017 |work=The Telegraph |access-date=2018-01-11 |language=en-GB |issn=0307-1235}}
* {{cite book |last1=Chuluun |first1=Sampildondov |last2=Bulag |first2=Uradyn E. |title=The Thirteenth Dalai Lama on the Run (1904–1906): Archival Documents from Mongolia |year=2013 |publisher=BRILL |isbn=978-9004254558}}
* {{cite book |last=Coleman |first=James William |title=The New Buddhism: The Western Transformation of an Ancient Tradition |publisher=Oxford University Press |year=2001 |isbn=0-19-513162-2}}
* {{cite book |title=T'oung Pao (通報) or Archives |editor1-first=Henri |editor1-last=Cordier |editor2-first=Paul |editor2-last=Pelliot |url=https://archive.org/stream/s2tungpaotoungp11corduoft |publisher=[[E.J. Brill]] |volume=XX1 |year=1922 |location=Leiden}}
* {{cite book |title=Buddha's Not Smiling: Uncovering Corruption at the Heart of Tibetan Buddhism Today |publisher=Motilal Banarsidass |first=Erik |last=Curren |year=2006 |isbn=978-81-208-3331-9}}
* {{cite journal |last=deJong |first=J. W. |title=A Brief History of Buddhist Studies in Europe and America |journal=The Eastern Buddhist |publisher=Eastern Buddhist Society |volume=7 |issue=1 |year=1974 |issn=0012-8708 |jstor=44361384 |pages=55–106 |url=http://www.jstor.org/stable/44361384 | access-date=2023-10-31}}
* {{cite book |last=Diemberger |first=Hildegard |title=When a Woman Becomes a Religious Dynasty: The Samding Dorje Phagmo of Tibet |url=https://archive.org/details/whenwomanbecomes0000diem |url-access=registration |date=2007 |publisher=Columbia University Press |isbn=978-0-231-14320-2}}
* {{cite book |last=Dongyal |first=Khenpo Tsewang |title=Light of Fearless Indestructible Wisdom: The Life and Legacy of His Holiness Dudjom Rinpoche |date=2008 |publisher=[[Snow Lion Publications]] |isbn=978-1-55939-304-1}}
* {{cite book |title=Of Rainbows and Clouds: The Life of Yab Ugyen Dorji as Told to His Daughter |first1=Yab Ugyen |last1=Dorji |first2=Ashi Dorji Wangmo |last2=Wangchuck |publisher=Serindia Publications |year=1999 |isbn=0-906026-49-0}}
* {{cite book |title=The Power-places of Central Tibet: The Pilgrim's Guide |year=1988 |first=Keith |last=Dowman |publisher=Routledge & Kegan Paul |isbn=0-7102-1370-0}}
* {{cite book |contributor-last=Drolma |contributor-first=Chönyi |contribution=Translator's Introduction |author=Dudjom Lingpa |title=A Clear Mirror: The Visionary Autobiography of a Tibetan Master |year=2012 |location=Hong Kong |publisher= Rangjung Yeshe Publications |isbn=978-9627341673 |oclc=780067518}}
* {{cite book |author=Dudjom Lingpa |editor1=Chagdud Tulku Rinpoche |editor1-link=Chagdud Tulku Rinpoche |editor2-last=Norbu |editor2-first=Padma Drimed |translator1=Richard Barron (Lama Chökyi Nyima) |translator2= Suzanne Fairclough |orig-year=1994 |year=2002 |edition=Rev. |title=Buddhahood Without Meditation: A Visionary Account Known as ''Refining One's Perception (Nang-jang)'' |script-title=bo:༄༅༎རང་བཞིན་རྫོགས་པ་ཆེན་པོའི་རང་ཞལ་མངོན་དུ་བྱེད་པའི་གདམས་པ་མ་བསྒོམ་སངས་རྒྱས་བཞུགས་སོ༎ |trans-title=ran bźin rdzogs pa chen po'i ranźal mnon du byed pa'i gdams pa zab gsan sñin po |location=Junction City, CA |publisher=Padma Publishing |isbn=1-881847-33-0}}
* {{cite journal |title=Time for Radical Change in How We Raise Our Tulkus |author=Dzongsar Jamyang Khyentse Rinpoche |author-link=Khyentse Norbu |date=August 22, 2016 |journal=[[Tricycle: The Buddhist Review]] |url=https://tricycle.org/article/dzongsar-jamyang-khyentse-tulkus/ |access-date=2023-11-06 |url-access=subscription}}
* {{cite news |title=Who Will Decide On The Dalai Lama's Successor — His Supporters Or Beijing |first=Lauren |last=Frayer |date=10 November 2019 |url=https://www.npr.org/2019/11/10/776052182/who-will-decide-on-the-dalai-lamas-successor-his-supporters-or-beijing |access-date=27 August 2020}}
* {{cite book |title=Tibet, Tibet: A Personal History of a Lost Land |year=2003 |first=Patrick |last=French |publisher=Alfred A. Knopf |place=New York |isbn=1-4000-4100-7}}
* {{cite web |first=Gaby |last=Hollmann |year=2006 |url=http://www.rinpoche.com/stories/tibet3.htm |title=History of Tibet – A Few Chapters (Part 3) |website=Rinpoche.com |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210416070806/http://rinpoche.com/stories/tibet3.htm |archive-date=2021-04-16}}
* {{cite book |last=Goldstein |first=Melvyn C. |title=A History of Modern Tibet, Volume 2: The Calm Before the Storm: 1951–1955 |year=2007 |publisher=University of California Press |isbn=978-0-520-24941-7 |url=https://archive.org/details/historyofmodernt00melv }}
* {{cite book |last1=Goldstein |first1=Melvyn C. |last2=Sherap |first2=Dawei |last3=Siebenschuh |first3=William R. |title=A Tibetan Revolutionary: The Political Life and Times of Bapa Phüntso Wangye |year=2004 |publisher=University of California Press |isbn=0-520-24089-8 |page= |url=https://archive.org/details/tibetanrevolutio0000gold }}
* {{cite news |last=Hyde |first=Marina |date=24 September 2015 |title=Has Steven Seagal proved you can be a Buddhist and a mascot for the arms trade? |work=The Guardian |url=https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/lostinshowbiz/2015/sep/24/steven-seagal-buddhist-and-mascot-for-arms-trade-azerbaijan |access-date=31 October 2023}}
* {{cite magazine |last=Jackson |first=Roger R. |title=The Tibetan Leonardo |date=November 8, 2012 |url=https://www.lionsroar.com/the-tibetan-leonardo/ |magazine=The Lion's Roar}}
* {{cite book |last=Jamgon Kongtrul |first=Lodro Taye |title=Enthronement: The Recognition of the Reincarnate Masters of Tibet and the Himalayas |year=1997 |place=Ithaca, New York |publisher=Shambhala |isbn=978-1559390835}}
* {{cite book |author=Jamgon Kongtrul |translator=Kalu Rinpoche Translation Group |year=2003 |title=The Treasury of Knowledge: Book One: Myriad Worlds |publisher=Shambhala Publications |isbn=978-1559398824}}
* {{cite book | last1=Juhasz | first1=Alexandra | last2=Lebow | first2=Alisa | title=A Companion to Contemporary Documentary Film | publisher=John Wiley & Sons | publication-place=Malden, Mass | date=2015-03-16 | isbn=978-0-470-67164-1}}
* {{cite book |title=The History of the Sixteen Karmapas of Tibet |author=Karma Thinley Rinpoche |publisher=Prajna Press |author-link=Karma Thinley Rinpoche |year=1980 |isbn=1-57062-644-8}}
* {{cite news |first=Stuart |last=Lachs |date=July 12, 2019 |title=Tibetan Buddhism Enters the 21st Century: Trouble in Shangri-la |work=Open Buddhism |url=https://openbuddhism.org/regions/north-america/2019/tibetan-buddhism-enters-the-21st-century-trouble-in-shangri-la/ |access-date=2023-11-02}}
* {{cite news |title=Movie Star Declared a Lama / Seagal elevated to sacred status in Tibetan Buddhism |last1=Lattin |first1=Don |work=SFGATE |date=20 June 1997 |access-date=31 October 2023 |url= https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Movie-Star-Declared-a-Lama-Seagal-elevated-to-2821779.php }}
* {{cite encyclopedia |last=Lessing |first=Ferdinand D. |title=Bogd |dictionary=Mongolian-English Dictionary |publisher=University of California Press |year=1960}}
* {{cite book |title=Miraculous 16th Karmapa: Incredible Encounters with the Black Crown Buddha |first=Norma |last=Levin |year=2013 |publisher=Shang Shung Publications}}
* {{cite news |first=Craig C. |last=Lewis |date=February 18, 2022 |url=https://www.buddhistdoor.net/news/passing-of-his-holiness-dudjom-sangye-pema-shepa-rinpoche-announced/ |title=Passing of His Holiness Dudjom Sangye Pema Shepa Rinpoche Announced |work=Buddhistdoor Global}}
* {{cite book |last=Lhundrub Dargye |first=Ngawang |year=2011 |title=The Hidden Life of the Sixth Dalai Lama |publisher=Lexington Books |isbn=978-0739150535}}
* {{cite book | last=Liechty | first=Mark | chapter=12. Imbibing Eastern Wisdom: Nepal as Dharma Destination | pages=323–366 | title=Far Out | publisher=University of Chicago Press | year=2017 | isbn=978-0-226-42894-9 | doi=10.7208/chicago/9780226429137.003.0012}}
* {{cite magazine |author=Lion's Roar Staff |date=July 14, 2015 |url=https://www.lionsroar.com/tenth-traleg-rinpoche-located-recognized/ |title=Tenth Traleg Rinpoche located, recognized |magazine=Lion's Roar |access-date=19 January 2022}}
* {{cite journal |last=Logan |first=Pamela |year=2004 |url=http://www.ivymedia.com/haq/onlineissues/winter2004issue.html |title=Tulkus in Tibet |journal=Harvard Asia Quarterly |volume=8 |number=1 |pages=15–23}}
* {{cite book |title=The History of Tibet,The Modern Period: 1895–1959, The Encounter with Modernity |volume=3 |first=Alex |last=McKay |isbn=0-415-30844-5 |year=2003|publisher=RoutledgeCurzon }}
* {{cite book |last=Mackenzie |first=Vicki |year=1996 |title=Reincarnation: The Boy Lama |publisher=Wisdom Publications |isbn=978-0861711086}}
* {{cite book |last=Mackerras |first=Colin |title=The New Cambridge Handbook of Contemporary China  |year=2001 |publisher=Cambridge University Press |isbn=978-0-521-78674-4}}
* {{cite journal |title=Reflections on Dzongsar Khyentse's 'How We Raise Tulkus' |first=Ken |last=McLeod  |date=September 15, 2016 |journal=[[Tricycle: The Buddhist Review]] |url=https://tricycle.org/article/reflections-on-dzongsar-khyentses-how-we-raise-tulkus/ |access-date=2023-11-05 |url-access=subscription}}
* {{cite web |first=Alison |last=Melnick |date=2007 |url=https://collab.itc.virginia.edu/wiki/renaissanceold/Karmapa.html |title=Karmapa Concept Encyclopedia Analysis |publisher=Collab.itc.virginia.edu |access-date=20 July 2020}}
* {{cite book |last=Midal |first=Fabrice |year=2005 |title=Recalling Chögyam Trungpa |publisher=Shambhala |isbn=1-59030-207-9}}
* {{cite book | last=Moran | first=Peter Kevin | title=Buddhism Observed | publisher=Routledge | publication-place=London | date=2004 | isbn=978-0-415-32596-7}}
* {{cite book |last=Mullin |first=Glenn H. |year=2001 |title=The Fourteen Dalai Lamas: A Sacred Legacy of Reincarnation |publisher=Clear Light Publishers |place=Santa Fe, New Mexico |isbn=1-57416-092-3}}
* {{cite magazine |first=Jan |last=Nattier |title=Visible and Invisible: The Politics of Representation in Buddhist America |magazine=Tricycle |volume=5 |number=1 |year=1995 |pages=42–9}}
* {{cite book |first=Khenpo Ngawang |last=Pelzang |title=A Guide to the Words of My Perfect Teacher |place=Boston |publisher=Shambhala |year=2004 |isbn=978-1-59030-073-2}}
* {{cite journal | last=Oldmeadow | first=Peter | title=Tibetan Buddhism and Globalisation | journal=Sydney Studies in Religion | date=2001 | issn=1444-5158 | url=https://openjournals.library.sydney.edu.au/SSR/article/view/233 | access-date=2023-11-01}}
* {{cite web |author=Orgyen Tobgyal Rinpoche |title=The Life of Jamyang Khyentse Wangpo |year= 1996 |url=http://www.lotsawahouse.org/tibetan-masters/orgyen-tobgyal-rinpoche/biography-khyentse-wangpo |access-date=2012-10-15}}
* {{cite magazine |first=Martine |last=Panzica |date=February 18, 2022 |url=https://www.lionsroar.com/passing-of-two-influential-nyingma-teachers-dudjom-rinpoche-iii-and-dodrubchen-rinpoche/ |title=Passing of two influential Nyingma teachers: Dudjom Rinpoche III and Dodrubchen Rinpoche |magazine=Lions Roar}}
* {{cite web |author=Penor Rinpoche |title=Advice Regarding Recognition of Tulkus (Steven Seagal) |work=palyul.org |date=1999 |access-date=31 October 2023 |url= https://palyul.org/wp/advice-regarding-recognition-of-tulkus-steven-seagal/}}
* {{cite book |last=Pommaret |first=Françoise |title=Bhutan |publisher=Passport Books (Odyssey) |year=1998 |isbn=0-8442-9966-9}}
* {{cite news |title=Reincarnation feudal, should end now: Dalai Lama amid successor row with China |first=Shri |last=Puri |date=26 October 2019 |url=https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/reincarnation-feudal-should-end-now-dalai-lama-amid-successor-row-with-china/articleshow/71769825.cms |newspaper=Times of India |access-date=27 August 2020}}
* {{cite journal |last=Ray |first=Reginald A. |title=Some Aspects of the Tulku Tradition in Tibet |journal=The Tibet Journal |volume=11 |number=4 |year=1986 |pages=35–69}}
* {{cite magazine |last=Remski |first=Matthew |date=April 13, 2021 |orig-date= September 28, 2020 |author-link=Matthew Remski |title=Survivors of an international Buddhist Cult Share Their Stories |url=https://thewalrus.ca/survivors-of-an-international-buddhist-cult-share-their-stories/ |magazine=The Walrus |access-date=21 October 2020}}
* {{cite book |last=Richardson |first=Hugh E. |title=Tibet and its history |year=1984 |publisher=Shambhala |location=Boston |isbn=978-0-87773-376-8 |edition=2nd}}
* {{cite book |author=Ringu Tulku |title=The Ri-me Philosophy of Jamgon Kongtrul the Great: A Study of the Buddhist Lineages of Tibet |year=2007 |publisher=Shambhala |isbn=978-1590304648}}
* {{cite book |title=The Politics of Bhutan |last=Rose |first=Leo E. |publisher=Cornell University Press |location=Ithaca |year=1977 |isbn=0-8014-0909-8}}
* {{cite book |title=Civilized Shamans: Buddhism in Tibetan Societies |first=Geoffery |last=Samuel |publisher=Smithsonian Institution Press |year=1993 |isbn=1-56098-231-4}}
* {{cite book |last=Shakabpa |first=Tsepon W. D. |year=1967 |title=Tibet: A Political History |place=New York |publisher=Yale University Press}}
* {{cite book |last=Sherrill |first=Martha |title=The Buddha from Brooklyn |publisher=Random House |year=2000 |isbn=0-679-45275-3}}
* {{cite book |last=Smith |first=E. Gene |author-link=E. Gene Smith |year=2001 |title=Among Tibetan Texts: History and Literature of the Himalayan Plateau |series=Studies in Indian and Tibetan Buddhism |publication-place=Sommerville, Massachusetts |publisher=Wisdom Publications |isbn=0-86171-179-3}}
* {{cite book |first=Cyrus |last=Stearns |title=King of the Empty Plain: The Tibetan Iron Bridge Builder Tangtong Gyalpo |year=2007 |publisher=Snow Lion Publications |isbn=978-1559392754}}
*{{cite book |first=Eric |last=Tagliacozzo |title=Asia Inside Out: Changing Times |date=2015 |publisher=Harvard University Press |isbn=978-0-674-96694-9}}
* {{cite book |last=Terhune |first=Lea |year=2004 |title=Karmapa: The Politics of Reincarnation |publisher=Wisdom Publications |isbn=978-0861711802}}
* {{cite book |first=Tulku |last=Thondup |year=2011 |title=Incarnation: The History and Mysticism of the Tulku Tradition of Tibet |place=Boston |publisher=Shambhala Publications |isbn=978-1590308394}}
* {{cite book |first=Tulku |last=Thondup |year=1996 |title=Masters of Meditation and Miracles |publisher=Shambhala |isbn=1-57062-113-6}}
* {{cite web |first=Khenchen |last=Thrangu Rinpoche |url=http://www.rinpoche.com/samadisutra.html |title=King of Samadhi Sutra: Oral commentaries given in Rinpoche's monastery in Boudhanath, Nepal |date=January 1993 |website=Rinpoche.com |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20010617183445/http://rinpoche.com/samadisutra.html |archive-date=2001-06-17}}
* {{cite web |url=http://www.rinpoche.com/controversy.htm |title=The Karmapa Controversy |author=Thrangu Rinpoche |date=n.d. |website=Rinpoche.com |access-date=29 July 2020 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200906095656/http://rinpoche.com/controversy.htm |archive-date=2020-09-06}}
* {{Cite web|url=http://search.lib.virginia.edu/catalog/libra-oa:3244|title=Lords of the Northern Treasures: The Development of the Tibetan Institution of Rule by Successive Incarnations|last=Valentine|first=Jay|date=2013|website=UVA Library {{!}} Virgo|language=en|access-date=2017-08-06}}
* {{cite journal |title=Tibetan Ani-s: The Nun's Life in Tibet |first=Janice D. |last=Willis |journal=The Tibet Journal |volume=IX |number=4 |date=Winter 1984 |publisher=Library of Tibetan Works & Archives |place=Dharamsala, India}}
* {{cite book |title=The Karmapa Prophecies |publisher=Motilal Banarsidass |first=Sylvia |last=Wong |year=2010 |isbn=978-81-208-3480-4}}
* {{cite book |last=Zangpo |first=Tsering Lama Jampal |year=1988 |title=The Astonishing Succession of Throne Holders of the Victorious and Powerful Palyul Tradition Called A Garland of Immortal Wish-fulfilling Trees |publisher=Snow Lion Publications |isbn=978-0937938645}}
* {{cite magazine |author=Zopa Rinpoche |date=April–June 2009 |title=Lama Yeshe Passes |magazine=Mandala |pages=40–45 |url=http://fpmt.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2009/03/LamaYeshePasses.pdf}}
{{refend}}
==Further reading==
{{refbegin|2|indent=yes}}
* {{cite journal |first=José Ignacio |last=Cabezón |date=February 2017 |title=On Tulku Lineages |journal=Revue d'Études Tibétaines |number=38 |pages=1–28 |url=https://himalaya.socanth.cam.ac.uk/collections/journals/ret/pdf/ret_38_02.pdf |ref=none}}
* {{cite web |first=Tenzin |last=Desal |date=July 30, 2019 |title=The Tibetan Tradition of Reincarnation and CCP's Assertion to Reign Sovereignty over 'Living Buddhas' |website=Tibet Policy Institute |url=https://tibetpolicy.net/the-tibetan-tradition-of-reincarnation-and-ccps-assertion-to-reign-sovereignty-over-living-buddhas/ |access-date=2023-11-02 |ref=none}}
* {{cite book |last=Gamble |first=Ruth |year=2018 |title=Reincarnation in Tibetan Buddhism: The Third Karmapa and the Invention of a Tradition |publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=978-0190690793 |ref=none}}
* {{cite journal |title=Reflections on Tulku Institution: Technical and Personal |first=Jeffrey |last=Hopkins |date=February 2017 |journal=Revue d'Études Tibétaines |number=38 |pages=241–264 |url=https://himalaya.socanth.cam.ac.uk/collections/journals/ret/pdf/ret_38_12.pdf |ref=none}}
* {{cite book |last1=Kunsang |first1=Lama |last2=Pemo |first2=Lama |last3=Aubele |first3=Marie |year=2012 |title=History of the Karmapas: The Odyssey of the Tibetan Masters with the Black Crown |publisher=Shambhala |isbn=978-1559393904 |ref=none}}
* {{cite journal |last=Manson |first=Charles |title=The Reincarnate Lamas Tradition in Central Asia |journal=Middle Way |volume=90 |number=2 |date=August 2015 |pages=105–10 |ref=none}}
* {{cite web |title=Magical Emanations: The Unexpected Lives of Western Tulkus |last=Miller |first=Andrea |work=Lion's Roar |date=12 March 2021 |access-date=30 October 2023 |url= https://www.lionsroar.com/magical-emanations-the-unexpected-lives-of-western-tulkus/ |ref=none}}
* {{cite news |first=Don |last=Oldenburg |title=The Unexpected Incarnation |newspaper=Washington Post |date=26 September 1988 |access-date=31 October 2023 |url= https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1988/09/26/the-unexpected-incarnation/d7b49d89-9199-4256-a812-471ead64c5b7/ |ref=none}}
* {{cite news |first=David |last=Pierson |date=11 October 2023 |orig-date=4 October 2023 |title=The 8-Year-Old Boy at the Heart of a Fight Over Tibetan Buddhism: He may have to defend the faith in Mongolia against pressure from China's ruling Communist Party |work=The New York Times |url=https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/04/world/asia/mongolia-tibetan-buddhism-bogd.html |access-date=2023-10-31 |ref=none}}
* {{cite book |editor-first=Vanessa R. |editor-last=Sasson |title=Little Buddhas: Children and Childhoods in Buddhist Texts and Traditions |year=2013 |publisher=OUP USA |isbn=978-0199945610 |ref=none}}
* {{cite book |last=Schwieger |first=Peter |year=2015 |title=The Dalai Lama and the Emperor of China: A Political History of the Tibetan Institution of Reincarnation |publisher=Columbia University Press |isbn=978-0231538602 |ref=none}}
* {{cite journal |last1=Trzebuniak |first1=Jacek |date=2014	|title=Analysis of Development of the Tibetan Tulku System in Western Culture	|journal=Polish Journal of the Arts and Culture	|volume=2 |issue=10	|pages=115–130 |url=http://www.pjac.uj.edu.pl/documents/30601109/7f0c0910-a200-4233-9431-e4c80582ef25 |ref=none}}
* {{cite journal |first=Nicole |last=Willock |title=The Revival of the Tulku Institution in Modern China: Narratives and Practices |journal=Revue d'Études Tibétaines |number=38 |date=February 2017 |pages=183–201 |url=https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1055&context=philosophy_fac_pubs |ref=none}}
* {{cite journal |last=Yu |first=D. S. |year=2006 |title=Genuine Charisma and Its Transmissibility: The Inner Landscape of Tulkus in Contemporary Tibetan Buddhist Revival in Khams and Golok |journal=The Tibet Journal |volume=31 |number=4 |pages=57–78 |jstor=43302627 |ref=none}}
{{refend}}
== External links ==
{{Commons category|Tulkus|<br />Tulkus}}
* [http://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/lam-rim/student-teacher-relationship/spiritual-teachers-and-spiritual-students/the-traditional-meaning-of-a-spiritual-teacher#n6 Reincarnate Lamas: Tulkus and Rinpoches] – section from Berzin, Alexander. 2000 ''The Traditional Meaning of a Spiritual Teacher''
* [http://mypage.direct.ca/w/wattj/jw/Tulku.htm Tulkus: Incarnate Lamas of Tibet – An Interview with His Holiness Sakya Trizin] – An excerpt from ''Testimonies of Tibetan Tulkus; A Research among Reincarnate Buddhist Masters in Exile'' by Danial Barlocher, Opuscula Tibetana, Rikon-Zurich, August 1982.
* [http://mypage.direct.ca/w/wattj/jw/Tulku-2.htm Tulkus: Incarnate Lamas of Tibet 2 – Interview with Sakya Gongma Dagchen Rinpoche] – excerpted from ''Testimonies of Tibetan Tulkus; A Research among Reincarnate Buddhist Masters in Exile'' by Danial Barlocher, Opuscula Tibetana, Rikon-Zurich, August 1982. (Interview translator: Cyrus Stearns).
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20081006153839/http://www.wisdom-books.com/FocusDetail.asp?FocusRef=11 Tulkus : Masters of Reincarnation] – focus article at WisdomBooks.com
{{Clear}}
{{TibetanBuddhism}}
{{Buddhism topics}}
{{Authority control}}
[[Category:Tibetan Buddhist titles]]
[[Category:Tulkus| ]]